Tender, fluffy layers of cake filled with earthy spices and carrots, frosted with a subtly tangy cream cheese buttercream. This is my twist on my grandma’s recipe, making it lighter and more flavorful with just the right amount of sweetness and that subtle hint of cream cheese frosting. Easter cakes will never be the same!

This post may contain affiliate links from which, at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission to keep this site running. Only products I myself would or do use are recommended.

Everyone has their own preference when it comes to carrot cake. Lots of carrot flavor vs. almost none. Bold cinnamon flavor or hardly any spice. Some people love their carrot cake filled with different textures from things like walnuts, chunky carrots, grapes, and even pineapple. Personally, I’ll just take some toasted walnuts on top and that’s all, thanks.

So when a friend asked me to make a carrot cake for her brother’s birthday, I thought I’d take the chance to reimagine grandma’s carrot cake. It’s fine and all, but it wasn’t my ideal carrot cake.

What resulted was a cake that blew me away. Soft and tender and fluffy. Super moist yet not dense. Lovely carrot flavor that was perfectly complemented by the spices and sweetness. Plus, I used a less-tangy cream cheese frosting. Partly because I was short on cream cheese. Partly because my husband isn’t a big fan, so I wanted something he’d eat, too.

It was perfection and will be a regular in my Easter rotation.

Why this recipe works

I think the biggest key was using freshly grated carrots. In the past, I’ve used pre-shredded carrots and just chopped them up to be smaller. It saved time but also dried out the cake. So this time, I spent the extra 5 minutes to peel then grate whole carrots. The flavor, color, and texture were all greatly improved as a result. Freshly grated carrots are far more moist than the pre-shredded kind, transforming the texture of your cake.

In addition to the carrots, I love how spicy this cake is. Not overly so, but just enough to make the carrots taste delicious, not like a health food. Plus, I’ve worked to tweak the ratio of ingredients so that the cake isn’t dry or dense and also doesn’t fall apart. It’s one of my favorite textures I’ve made in a long time.

Plus, you can’t go wrong with a cream cheese frosting on carrot cake! It’s classic! Of course, you could easily sub something like my vanilla bean frosting or cinnamon vanilla bean.

Key ingredients

Flour. Be sure to spoon then level this, so you don’t pack it in, and always sift!

Baking powder and baking powder. Be sure both are fresh. The combination creates the perfect rise and fluffiness for this cake.

Salt. Sea salt is best!

Spices. I used cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and allspice. The combination was absolutely perfect.

Eggs. Be sure they are fresh and room temperature.

Brown sugar. I used mostly brown sugar to give moisture and a slightly caramelized flavor.

Sugar. A bit of regular sugar helps the cake rise well.

Vanilla. Be sure it’s pure extract for the best flavor.

Oil. I prefer avocado or grape seed oil, as they are light, tasteless, and “healthy”. However, vegetable or canola will work, too.

Carrots. Use fresh, whole carrots. Peel them first to remove the dirty exterior then finely grate them right before using.

Raisins. These are optional, and they won’t be super noticeable in the cake, but they add some great flavor and moisture.

Walnuts. Personally, I like toasting these and chopping them very finely. I also only add a small amount to avoid a super nutty cake, but you can use up to 1 cup before the cake won’t hold together well.

Applesauce. This cake is basically a health food. Not really, but the applesauce helps keep it moist without weighing it down or making it dense.

Cream cheese frosting. You can sub vanilla bean or cinnamon vanilla bean—both have a wonderfully earthy flavor that goes very well with the carrot cake. Brown sugar spice is also a great option!

How to make carrot cake

Prep mix-ins. Chop walnuts and raisins. Peel then finely grate carrots.

Sift then whisk dry ingredients. Don’t skip the sifting, as it is necessary to prevent clumps and prevent an overly mixed batter.

Beat eggs until pale and fluffy. This takes a few minutes, so don’t skimp on the beating!

Add sugar and vanilla. Beat until well-mixed.

Stream in oil. Do this with the mixer on to help emulsify the oil.

Fold in flour. Don’t worry about getting it all incorporated, as the next step will take care of that.

Fold in mix-ins. Again, do this gently so it’s not over mixed.

Bake. Rotate pans if you don’t have a convection oven.

Make cream cheese frosting. Do this once the cakes are cooled. Otherwise, you must refrigerate it while you wait, which can cause it to firm up too much and requires softening, which is annoying.

Frost cake. This is up to your heart’s desire! You can cut the cakes in half or leave them whole. It all depends on if you’re a frosting or cake fan.

Enjoy!

Tips and FAQ’s about this recipe

Grate fresh carrots

This is v important. Grating fresh carrots ensures plenty of moisture so your cake has that perfect texture. If you use dried out carrots, it will likely cause your cake to fall apart somewhat, especially as you cut and serve it.

Do I have to use nuts and raisins?

No! You can leave these out, although I do highly recommend the raisins. Chopping them means you won’t have big chunks. You may not even notice them in the baked cake, as they tend to mesh with the batter as it bakes.

The color will deepen as it bakes

This freaked me out the first time. The batter is light brown but the baked cake is a deeper golden. Just use the toothpick test to make sure you have moist crumbs and no raw batter. Check a little early so you ensure some moist crumbs. Otherwise, the cake ends up being over baked, as it does continue cooking for a bit once you remove it from the oven.

Use any frosting you like

I paired this with the classic cream cheese frosting. However, a lot of people don’t care for cream cheese frosting. I also love this cake with vanilla bean and cinnamon vanilla bean. Brown sugar spice buttercream would also be a great option, although I haven’t actually tried that one. Whatever you prefer is what’s best!

My tools

Here are my must-have tools I use for making this cake. Affiliate links provided.

Stand mixer or handheld mixer

Mesh sieve (because sifting is KEY for a fluffy cake)

All-rubber spatula (this makes scraping the bowl easier as the batter and frosting doesn’t get all over a wooden handle!)

Silicone liners for 8” cake (or for 6” cakes)

8” aluminum cake pans or 6” aluminum cake pans (I’ve found nonstick doesn’t bake as evenly)

Cooling rack

Offset spatula for frosting the cake

Grater and vegetable peeler (for the carrots)

You might also like:

Grandma’s Carrot Cake

Malted Milk Chocolate Robin’s Egg Cake

Dirty Chai Latte Cake

Ginger Bourbon Peach Spice Cake

Grandma’s Spiced Apple Cake